‘Church’s record on diversity isn’t good’ admits next Archbishop of York

The new Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell at York Minster. Photograph: Danny Lawson/PA Wire
17 Dec 2019 @ 3.39 pm
| News

The next Archbishop of York has admitted the Church of England’s record on ethnic diversity “isn’t good” as he was announced as the successor to Dr John Sentamu, the church’s most senior black bishop.

Stephen Cottrell, the current Bishop of Chelmsford, will take on the role in June 2020, despite speculation it would go to a woman.


Speaking during a press conference in London on Tuesday, the married father-of-three renewed his calls for greater equality for black and minority ethnic (BAME) clergy in the upper echelons of the church, and said bishops “must take responsibility” for a lack of diversity.

He said he was “humbled and excited at the prospect” of becoming the 98th Archbishop of York, and said restoring faith in the church in the wake of historic child abuse allegations would be his “top priority”.

‘No place for homophobia’

The new Archbishop of York outside the Minster
Bishop Cottrell also pledged the church should welcome “absolutely everyone, regardless of their sexuality,” adding “there is absolutely no place for homophobia in the Church”.

The 61-year-old previously described how the church was “going backwards” in its approach to recruiting ethnic minorities to senior roles.

Acknowledging the issue on Tuesday, he said: “When I do hang up my mitre I hope the church will look different, it will look more diverse but our record isn’t good and, dare I say it, we bishops must take responsibility.”

The new Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell (right) arrives with the Dean of York Dr Jonathan Frost at York Minster
File photo from 2014 of the Right Reverend Stephen Cottrell and Queen Elizabeth II during her visit to Chelmsford’s cathedral. Photograph: Arthur Edwards/The Sun/PA Wire

Paying tribute to his predecessor, the bishop said:

  • I will receive the baton from Archbishop Sentamu. These aren’t just big shoes to fill, but a big heart and a big vision.

    However, I am not daunted.

    Archbishop Sentamu and I have worked together in mission on many occasions and I hope to build on the work he has pioneered.

    Working alongside the Archbishop of Canterbury (Justin Welby), I hope to help the church be more joyful and more effective in sharing the gospel and bringing hope and unity to our nation.

He added: “I now look forward to returning and being a voice for the North, sharing the liberating good news of the gospel and helping to address the discrepancies of wealth and opportunity that too often favour the South.”

Hold the government to account

He looks quite at home
Speaking after his announcement on Tuesday, the married father-of-three said it is the Church of England’s job to “hold the politicians to account” on their one nation promises.

The country has been “defined… by how we voted one day in June,” he said, but is about to “enter into a new chapter in our life together” by leaving the European Union. He added:

  • The Prime Minister has spoken this week about being one nation, I both want to support that wholeheartedly and I also want to hold the Government to account, that is the job of the church.

    So we’re not just one nation, we’re also one humanity and it’s reminding our politicians of those truths.

Bishop Cottrell described “the last few years” as “not… terribly healthy”, and said: “There’s a job to do, which is to hold the politicians to account, to scrutinise what’s going on in our nation but also to be out there serving the needs of the poor and the marginalised, and being a voice for them.

“That’s the kind of Church I want to be part of and I want to help, with others, to build that kind of Church.”

‘The gospel in his belly’

The new Archbishop of York with Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby at Convocation Hall inside Church House Westminster today. Photograph: Yui Mok/PA Wire
Dr Sentamu said the announcement “gladdened my heart”.

He added: “Bishop Stephen Cottrell has the gospel in his belly and a tiger in the tank.”

Bishop Cottrell said it was was important that “survivors’ voices are heard” in the wake of claims being examined by the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse.

He said:

  • When I look at the challenges that lie ahead, I think this is probably the most important.

    We need to put our house in order, we need to ensure that the church is a safe place for everyone.

    I believe we are doing really good work in that area but I am not complacent and I know there’s still much to do.

    Particularly it’s about listening to survivors and making sure their voices are heard but I hope in the work I will do as Archbishop of York with the Archbishop of Canterbury, making the church safe for everyone will be a really top priority.

‘I am not daunted’: Stephen Cottrell

Bishop Cottrell has also been vocal in calling for tolerance and understanding in the national debate since the Brexit vote and subsequent elections.

In August, he was among the signatories to an open letter to the Government from the Church calling on it not to leave the EU without a deal.

Bishop Cottrell was ordained as a deacon in 1984 and as a priest in 1985.

The Tottenham Hotspur supporter is described on his website as a keen writer, with interests in reading, cooking and music.

The role of Archbishop of York itself dates back to St Paulinus in 627AD.

‘Out of touch’

Criticised: Bishop Cottrell
The National Secular Society (NSS) criticised Bishop Cottrell’s appointment, pointing out he blocked an amendment that would have made it easier for the Church of England to conduct same-sex marriages.

NSS chief executive Stephan Evans said: “The appointment of Stephen Cottrell to the second most senior position in the Church of England is a reminder that our established church retains social attitudes which are out of touch with the views of the British people.

“This anti-gay institution shouldn’t lead our national ceremonies, have seats in our legislature or run state-funded schools. It should be disestablished so church and state can go their separate ways.”